If I’m Really Honest

Want to seek truth without tribalism? Wish you could be fully honest instead of carrying your team's flag? This is a place where ignorance isn’t punished, curiosity is rewarded, and conflict doesn’t mean contempt.

Host Jamin Coller sits down with people you’re not “supposed” to talk to - former extremists, outspoken pastors, rabbis, activists, skeptics, believers, and thinkers from every corner of the spectrum. They share stories and challenge ideas that most of us were taught to avoid, whether the topic is faith, politics, science, identity, or the messy places in between.

This isn’t about winning arguments or trading insults. If you’re tired of echo chambers and ready to explore the conversations that matter most, subscribe to If I’m Really Honest and join the growing community willing to embrace the most courageous idea: Maybe I'm wrong.

Listen on:

  • Apple Podcasts
  • YouTube
  • Podbean App
  • Spotify
  • Amazon Music
  • iHeartRadio
  • PlayerFM
  • Podchaser
  • BoomPlay

Episodes

5 days ago

Gary Noesner spent more than 30 years with the FBI, served as Chief of the FBI's Crisis Negotiation Unit, led negotiations during the Waco siege, helped reshape modern hostage negotiation training, and authored the influential book Stalling for Time.
In this conversation, Gary and I explore what actually works when people are at their worst. We discuss the lessons of Waco, why negotiation should almost always take precedence over force, how empathy differs from agreement, the psychology of trust, what makes a great negotiator, the dangers of authority without self-control, and how active listening can transform everything from hostage situations to everyday relationships.
Book – Stalling for Time: https://amzn.to/4oj50PZWebsite: https://www.garynoesner.com
If I'm Really HonestWebsite: https://www.ifimreallyhonest.com
Superfan Community:https://www.jamincoller.com/iirh_Superfans
#IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong

Thursday Jun 18, 2026

Joel Salatin (@FarmLikeALunatic) is one of the world's most influential voices in regenerative agriculture. He is the co-owner of Polyface Farm, author of more than a dozen books, featured prominently in The Omnivore's Dilemma, Food, Inc., and numerous documentaries, and has spent decades challenging conventional assumptions about food, farming, government regulation, and sustainability.
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@farmlikealunaticJoel's Books: https://amzn.to/4uHplQJWebsite: https://polyfacefarm.com/
If I'm Really Honest: https://www.ifimreallyhonest.comSuperfan Community: https://www.jamincoller.com/iirh_Superfans
#IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong

Thursday Jun 11, 2026

Nicholas Christakis is a physician, sociologist, bestselling author, Yale professor, director of the Human Nature Lab, pioneer of social network science, and author of Blueprint, Connected, and Apollo's Arrow. His research has transformed how we understand friendship, cooperation, social contagion, tribalism, and the evolutionary origins of human society.
For the Love of Science (YouTube): https://www.youtube.com/@NAChristakis
Human Nature Lab: https://humannaturelab.net/
If I'm Really Honest:https://IfImReallyHonest.com
Become a Superfan:https://JaminColler.com/iirh_Superfans
#IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong

Thursday Jun 04, 2026

Sean B. Carroll is one of the world's leading evolutionary biologists, a bestselling science author, former Vice President for Science Education at the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, recipient of the National Academy of Sciences Stephen Jay Gould Prize, and a pioneer of evolutionary developmental biology ("evo devo").
In this conversation, we explore Darwin's life and character, the evidence for evolution, why evolutionary biology is often misunderstood, the relationship between faith and science, tribalism, COVID-era trust in institutions, and how science can be a source of awe and wonder rather than cynicism.
Guest Links:Books: https://www.amazon.com/Fortunate-Events-Chance-Making-Planet-ebook/dp/B086YHXHPL
Official Website: https://seanbcarroll.com
If I'm Really Honest:https://IfImReallyHonest.com
Become a Superfan:https://JaminColler.com/iirh_Superfans
#IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong

Thursday May 28, 2026

Brad Duchaine is one of the world’s leading researchers on face perception.He’s a Professor and Chair of Psychological and Brain Sciences at Dartmouth College, co-founder of Faceblind.org, and one of the foremost experts on prosopagnosia (face blindness) and prosopometamorphopsia (PMO)—the rare condition where faces appear visually distorted.
PMO: https://prosopometamorphopsia.faceblind.org/Prosopagnosia: https://www.faceblind.org/
More from If I’m Really Honest: https://IfImReallyHonest.comSuperfan Page: https://JaminColler.com/iirh_Superfans
#IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong

Thursday May 21, 2026

"Flat Earth Dave" Weiss of @flatearthdave is one of the foremost voices in the flat earth community. We talk about:* The emotional cost of changing your mind* Losing friends and family over beliefs* Distrust of institutions and authority* Why Dave walked away from a successful career* Whether truth-seeking becomes isolating* The psychology of conspiracy thinking* Why he believes Flat Earth changes everything
https://www.FlatEarthDave.com
More from If I’m Really Honest: https://IfImReallyHonest.comSuperfan Page: https://JaminColler.com/iirh_Superfans
#IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong

Thursday May 14, 2026

"Professor Dave" Farina of @ProfessorDaveExplains is one of the internet’s largest science education and debunking channels.
In this episode, I sit down with Dave Farina (Professor Dave Explains) to talk about conspiracy theories, anti-science thinking, Joe Rogan, flat earth, the psychology of belief, and why intelligent people can still fall for ideas that don’t hold up under scrutiny.
We also discuss:
* Why misinformation spreads so effectively online* Whether major influencers actually believe what they say* The role podcasts now play in shaping public opinion* Why distrust in institutions has exploded* Whether science literacy is getting better or worse* And how identity gets tied to belief systems
If I’m Really Honest:https://IfImReallyHonest.comhttps://JaminColler.com/iirh_Superfans
#IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong

Thursday May 07, 2026

Dr. Daniel Whiteson is a theoretical physicist at CERN, a professor at University of California, Irvine, and a contributor to the discovery of the Higgs boson. He is also the co-host of the podcast “Daniel and Kelly’s Extraordinary Universe” and author of popular science books exploring the limits of human understanding.
What if physics isn’t actually “real”… but just the way humans happen to describe reality?
In this conversation, we explore whether our understanding of the universe is objective truth or a human-centered framework. We talk about alien intelligence, the limits of human cognition, why the Big Bang is widely misunderstood, and whether we might encounter truths we’re simply incapable of understanding. This is less about answers—and more about questioning the assumptions we didn’t even realize we were making.
GUEST LINKS"Do Aliens Speak Physics?" https://www.amazon.com/Do-Aliens-Speak-Physics-Questions/dp/1324064641
Podcast: https://www.danielandkelly.org
MORE FROM Jamin / IIRHhttps://IfImReallyHonest.comhttps://JaminColler.com/iirh_Superfans
#IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong

Thursday Apr 30, 2026

Mark Sargent  ⁨@markksargent⁩  is a leading figure in the Flat Earth movement. Rather than focusing on proving or disproving claims, this conversation dives into the experience of belief - what leads someone there, what keeps them there, and what it costs relationally.
From frustration and fear to community and identity, this is a conversation about how humans make sense of the world, even when that world stops making sense.
Mark's Channel and Flat-Earth Clues: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y5IsLBMjhtI&list=PLltxIX4B8_URNUzDE2sXctnUAEXgEDDGn
More from Jamin: https://IfImReallyHonest.comSuper Fans: https://JaminColler.com/iirh_Superfans#IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong

Thursday Apr 23, 2026

In this conversation, I sit down with Dr. Joshua Bowen to explore- Where the Bible came from.- Whether the Bible actually endorses slavery- How ancient people thought about morality- Why stories like the flood appear across multiple cultures...and why the Bible might become more interesting after belief, not less
Guest Links:YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@DigitalHammurabiWebsite: https://digitalhammurabi.comPatreon: https://www.patreon.com/DigitalHammurabiBook: An Atheist's Guide to the Old Testament https://www.amazon.com/Atheist-Handbook-Old-Testament/dp/1736592068
Misquoting Jesus https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLmutpnyeVQcrRNOzPWdEothXcCVo2Npfv&si=bK0I4rcut__8_iJ8
My Linkshttps://IfImReallyHonest.comhttps://JaminColler.com/iirh_Superfans
#IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong

Copyright 2026 All Rights Reserved

Podcast Powered By Podbean

Version: 20241125